"There are certain things that I just know that I have to do because we are brothers" : a discourse analysis of young black men's engagement with popular representations of brotherhood

Abstract

The present study analyses the discourses that young black South African men employed when they engaged with popular representations of brotherhood in the media. In particular the study explores how these particular young men view masculinity within brothering and what the implications of 'doing brothering' are as a result of this view. Drawing on discursive psychology, the study is located in a social constructionist theoretical framework and uses a qualitative methodological approach. The data used in the discourse analysis was gathered through focus group discussion of scenes from the television show Generations. The discourse analysis produced two major discourses in which there were different constructions of masculinity each influencing the way in which brothering was done. The first discourse constructed a 'dutiful man' who performs his brotherly obligations separately from his emotions, this discourse is in line with discourses of hegemonic masculinity where men are expected to fulfil obligations and are not expected to be emotional. Resisting this discourse at times, some participants in this study did occasionally construct men as having rich emotional lives such that the quality of interaction with brothers is constructed as more important, in terms of building intimate fraternal relationships, than the amount of interaction with them. The second major discourse constructs the 'ideal man' in two different ways: as the 'good man' and the 'unscrupulous man'. The 'good man', like the 'dutiful man' performs the obligations society has placed on him, but does not receive the social esteem that is given to the 'unscrupulous man', who is successful and financially powerful. Although both these types of men are spoken of as possessing masculinity, the 'good man' is constructed as holding onto a type of masculinity that does not have a place in contemporary society. The findings suggest that brothering informs the way in which men take up certain masculine positions. The study contributes to our understanding of the construction of gender identity within familial relationships, specifically the adult brother-brother relationship.