Baseline assessments for foundation phase reading in isiXhosa: a case study

Abstract

The main objective of this study was to investigate the use of baseline assessments for reading in isiXhosa in Foundation Phase. It focused on how teachers conduct baseline assessments, the assessment tools they use, and their responsiveness to baseline assessments data in terms of curriculum planning and practice, given the lack of explicit guidelines and tools specifically developed for African languages. The lack of clarity may lead teachers to assume that the same assessment approaches and practices apply across all official languages despite their linguistic and sociolinguistic differences. Vygotsky's socio-cultural theory of learning and Biggs' concept on constructive alignment are used as the theoretical and conceptual framework for this study. The premise for this study was that it would be problematic to apply similar assessment approaches and use the same tools for all official South African languages. The socio-cultural approach emphasises the importance of language learning and learning generally according to the context within which language occurs. The main research sites are two Quintile 1 schools in a township in Makhanda District. These schools have been receiving external intervention which includes a baseline assessment for isiXhosa reading from Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs). This study sought to provide some insights on whether previous assessments have informed subsequent teaching practices. The findings of the study revealed that the most prominent tool for assessing reading in isiXhosa is Early Grade Reading Assessment (EGRA) and the tools used by external literacy interventions in the two schools were adapted versions of EGRA. Additionally, the subtasks in the baseline assessment tools used were aligned to the linguistic features of isiXhosa besides the nonsense word component. Furthermore, teachers were assessing and teaching reading at lower levels than expected in the grades 2 and 3 in this study. This study recommends that teachers respond to the baseline assessment data appropriately to develop reading competencies. In addition, there is need for an alignment between the linguistic features, the curriculum and strategies of teaching reading.